Are tourists safe in North Korea – or unwitting pawns in the regime's game?

Are tourists safe in North Korea – or unwitting pawns in the regime's game?

Latest detention of American citizen prompts scrutiny on DPRK travel industry and the tours operating there

 An American university student’s recent arrest in North Korea has rekindled questions about whether US tourists who visit the country are unwittingly offering themselves up as valuable pawns in Pyongyang’s political game.

The detention of Otto Warmbier, a 21-year-old University of Virginia economics student who spent his christmas holiday in North Korea, comes at a particularly difficult time in relations between the US and DPRK.

North Korea claims it has arrested US student for 'hostile act'

 Read more

Just days after his detention in early January the North conducted what it said was its first H-bomb test, an act of provocation that further isolated the country from the international community.

According to Warmbier’s travel agency, Young Pioneer Tours, the student was almost boarding his plane home when North Korean officials pulled him aside and arrested him for allegedly committing a “hostile act” against the state.

Authorities later said Warmbier is under investigation after he acted with the “tacit connivance of the US government and under its manipulation.”

Troy Collings, director of Young Pioneer tours, said they couldn’t comment on the case but emphasised that “every arrest [of a tourist ] that has occurred has, to our knowledge, been with context.”

Despite Warmbier’s detention none of the major North Korean travel agencies have cancelled their upcoming trips, stressing that almost all Americans who travel to the DPRK return home without incident.

The US state department currently “strongly recommends against all travel to the DPRK” due to the “risk of arrest and long-term detention due to the DPRK’s inconsistent application of its criminal laws.”

Young Pioneer Tours says Warmbier is the first of its 7,000 clients over the past eight years to face arrest.

New Jersey-based Uri Tours also said that it has had only one such case in 15 years – American Matthew Miller, who ripped up his tourist visa on arrival in what he has said was a deliberate attempt to get arrested.

“We serve about 1,000 travellers per year on average to the DPRK,” Uri Tours CEO, Andrea Lee, said. “We’ve taken many American tourists and with the exception of Matthew Miller, they’ve all returned safely with positive feedback.”

About 40% of the company’s travel clients are American, but Lee said American visitors are not treated differently from other tourists.

“Critics claim that tourism is an avenue for the DPRK government to arrest Americans as political hostages. However, this has not been our experience,” she said.

Analysis Tourism or propaganda: how ethical is your North Korean holiday?

Kim Jong-un wants two million foreign visitors a year by 2020, but debate rages over whether travellers are a force for good – or merely prop up the regime

Political negotiation

As the two countries have no diplomatic relations, senior US officials are often required to fly to North Korea to personally negotiate the release of their citizens.

Former president Bill Clinton was forced to make a visit to Pyongyang to secure the release of American journalists Euna Lee and Laura Ling in 2009. Both had crossed the border from China illegally.

Jeffrey Fowle was also detained for six months in 2014 for leaving a bible in a local club – an act considered to be a criminal offence in the DPRK. He was only let go after US spy chief James Clapper negotiated his release alongside the Korean-American missionary, Kenneth Bae.

Response:
This article highlights a problem that has been happening. Additionally, with the North Korean videos we have recently been watching, this gives us more perspective. The tone of this article is quite inconsistent because the content of the article varies from the title. The title makes it sound like the article is going to describe that all the tourists North Korea are only allowed into the country for the government's purpose.  However, the article basically stated that the tourists who get arrested are an anomaly. Those people are committing crimes blatantly against North Korea. However, North Korea is very inconsistent on how arrest people, which creates danger for anyone who willingly enters North Korea. The inconsistency of the article gives this article unclear bias. Generally, I think the bias is directed towards that North Korea is essentially okay to go with special permission, of course. 

Cite:

Talmadge, Eric. "Are Tourists Safe in North Korea – or Unwitting Pawns in the Regime's Game?" Theguardian. Guardian News and Media Limited, 28 Jan. 2016. Web. 2 Feb. 2016.